Figments of a Fragment, or Fragments of a Figment

Imagination is our only reality. Which is to say that what we call our reality is in fact imagined. What we call our environment is composed of events in spacetime, events in timespace, happenings that only exist as they are going out of existence. They cannot be captured or held. They cannot be fixed or frozen. They cannot be known directly and immediately.

The events that make up our environment are fleeting and fugitive, elusive and evasive, oblique and mysterious. Our access to whatever is going on out there is terribly limited and entirely indirect, and as a consequence, we have no choice but to make things up as we go along.

The reality we think that we inhabit is an imagined reality. We are all citizens of an imagined country, members of an imagined community. Imagination is an environment that surrounds us, that we live and love and work and play within. Where there is life, there is imagination. Where there is imagination, there is no exit, as long as there is life.

Imagination is an environment, and an environment is composed of events. Therefore, imagination too is made up of events. Imagination, it follows, is not a thing. It is not something we have, or that we lack. Imagination is something that we do. Like thinking. Or breathing.

There is no such thing as imagination. There is only imagining. A verb, rather than a noun. An action and activity. An act that we perform, a performance that we conduct, often for an audience of one, one’s own self.

Imagination is an event. Imagination may be said to occur only within a mind, within some form of consciousness. But it may well be that it is through a set of acts of imagination that mind and consciousness come into existence, that they emerge out of a collective series of imaginings.

A book, a play, a poem, a film, a story, a drawing, a painting, a piece of music, etc., may be products of imagination, but the products are not imagination itself. They are the effects, not the cause.

Imagination begins with memory. Indeed, memory constitutes a primal form of imagination. To remember is to imagine. When we remember, we do not playback a recording, we call something up, we recall something, something summoned up out of the depths. We imagine, or rather re-imagine, what we once experienced. What we imagine we experienced is not the same experience as what we experienced in the past. Neither is it the same experience when we remember repeatedly. Each remembering is a new experience, a new act of imagining.

The imagined past may be more or less faithful to what actually occurred, but it is never identical to it. Memory is a map of a territory that is no longer available to us. A map of an imagined territory. A map of a map. We imagine our own imaginings.

Experience based on sense perception is more than the passive reception of information from outside of ourselves. It is the active processing of the sensory data that we take in, the filtering and organizing and interpreting of sensory data. It is the making of meaning. This too is a primal form of imagination. As the saying goes, we see things not as they are, but as we are.

Sensory data is a response to stimuli that are nothing more than irritations of our nervous systems. Irritations that cause nerve cells to fire in varying sequences and combinations, until they reach the brain where the data is processed. Until they reach the mind, where we make sense of what our senses convey to us. The making of meaning out of the irritation of nerve endings and the resulting cascade of signals they produce is a pure act of imagination. Our meaning making may be of a modest sort, as when we recognize a familiar face or place. Or it may be a grand form of imagining, as when we interpret natural events as omens and portents, or use them to generate theories and hypotheses. Moreover, the sensory data that we imagine with may be generated from within, as when we hear voices and see visions, or feel a phantom pain, or when we are asleep and dreaming.

We imagine when we remember what we once experienced, and that enables us to imagine past events that we never experienced for ourselves. Experience and memory also allow us to imagine events that have yet to occur. Events that will be and events that may be. Events that could be and events that should be. We can imagine how events that occurred in the past might repeat themselves in the future. We can imagine past events that never actually occurred, and predict, project, and plan for future events that never happened before. The failure to anticipate unprecedented events is often referred to as a failure of imagination.

At its best, the act of imagination is a creative act, resulting in works of art. Innovations and inventions. Enhanced understanding and enlightenment. In progress. Making things better. Repairing the world. Improving the environment. Building new realities. Utopia.

At its worst, the act of imagination is a destructive act. The imagination of disaster. Substituting illusions for ideals. Delusions for dreams. Acts that cause damage and harm. The ushering in of the fall. The creation of catastrophe.

Imagination is an environment. Experience and memory are contained within my imagination. I can be lost in my imagination. I can be found in my imagination. I retreat to my imagination for safety and comfort. At once a humble home, and a theater where I am both audience and actor, as well as a palace of magnificent proportions, my imagination is a construction that can be expanded and enriched. My imagination is not limited to my own thoughts, or contained within my own mind, but extends beyond me to regions that are shared with others, through acts of collaboration, through our collective imagining.

We imagine. We imagine our reality. We imagine ourselves. We imagine ourselves imagining. Remembering, we imagine ourselves imagining in the past. Self-consciously, we imagine ourselves imagining in the present. Speculatively, we imagine ourselves imagining in the future.

Imagination is only what we imagine it to be.

Imagination is only a figment.


Lance Strate is Professor of Communications & Media Studies at Fordham University (NYC), President of the Institute of General Semantics, and author of the book, Media Ecology: An Approach to Understanding the Human Condition.